Sell Appreciated Stock Before Colorado’s 2027 Tax Increase?

Taxes
Gabe Motta, CFP®, MBA, AWMA™, Founder and Wealth Advisor at Inclinevest Wealth Management Gabe Motta, CFP®, MBA, AWMA™
Founder & Wealth Advisor

TAX PLANNING & APPRECIATED STOCK

Should You Sell Appreciated Stock Before Colorado's 2027 Tax Increase?

I'm Gabe Motta, a financial planner based in Colorado. I work with clients across the country, and many of the people reading this live here and own stock, options or a business with a large built-in gain.

Colorado voters approved Amendment 87 in the November 2026 election, and I cover the full bracket breakdown in my guide to Colorado Amendment 87 tax planning. Starting in tax year 2027, the state's 4.4% flat income tax gives way to graduated rates that reach 8.4% on taxable income above $1 million. If you're planning to sell a large position, you may be wondering whether to do it before December 31.

Charles Schwab logo Investments at Charles Schwab Based in Colorado, Serving Clients Nationwide CFP® Professionals Fee-Only Fiduciary NAPFA XYPN

Quick Answer: Should You Sell Before the Colorado Tax Increase?

It depends on how much income you expect in 2027. Amendment 87 lowers Colorado tax slightly for taxable income under about $500,000 and raises it above that. If your 2027 income will stay under $500,000, the new rates give you no reason to rush a sale.

If a large gain would push your 2027 taxable income well past $500,000, selling in 2026 could save real money, because the gain would be taxed at 4.4% instead of 7.4% to 8.4%. That only helps if you were going to sell anyway, and it has to be weighed against paying the tax earlier, your federal tax bracket and your other goals.

Don't let a state tax change be the only reason to sell. Use it as one input in a multiyear tax projection.

What Amendment 87 Changes

Colorado has taxed income at a flat rate since 1987, and the current rate is 4.4%. Amendment 87 removes the constitutional requirement for a single rate and creates six brackets starting in 2027. Each rate applies only to the income that falls inside its bracket, the same way the federal system works.

Colorado Taxable Income Current Rate Rate Under Amendment 87
$25,000 or less 4.4% 3.7%
$25,001 to $100,000 4.4% 4.2%
$100,001 to $500,000 4.4% 4.4%
$500,001 to $750,000 4.4% 7.4%
$750,001 to $1,000,000 4.4% 7.9%
More than $1,000,000 4.4% 8.4%

Source: Colorado Legislative Council Blue Book, Amendment 87, Table 1.

Three details matter for planning. First, the brackets are applied to federal taxable income as modified by Colorado law. Second, the brackets aren't adjusted for inflation, so more income lands in the higher brackets over time. Third, the same dollar thresholds apply to single filers and married couples filing jointly, so a married couple reaches the higher brackets at the same income as one person. The new rates also apply to businesses as well as individuals.

For a deeper look at the marriage penalty, Roth conversions, equity compensation, business owners and residency questions, see my full guide to Colorado Amendment 87 tax planning for high earners. This article focuses on one question, whether to realize gains before the end of 2026.

Voters also rejected Proposition 136, a separate measure that would have capped the state income tax rate at 4.4%. With that measure defeated, the graduated rates are set to take effect for tax year 2027. Counties are still completing their official canvass, with results due to the Secretary of State by November 25, 2026.

Amendment 87 is new, and the legislature and the Colorado Department of Revenue may issue guidance on how it works in practice. Check the latest details with your tax professional before you act.

Who the New Rates Affect

Most Colorado taxpayers will see a small cut. The Legislative Council estimated that taxpayers with Colorado taxable income below $510,834 would owe less, by as much as $325 a year, and taxpayers above that level would owe more.

That makes the decision a narrow one. The planning question matters most if you expect Colorado taxable income above $500,000 in 2027, and it matters a great deal if you expect to cross $1 million.

For many people, income that high happens only once. Selling a concentrated stock position, exercising stock options, closing on a business, selling a rental property or converting a large IRA to a Roth can all create a single year with an unusually large amount of taxable income.

What the New Rates Cost at Different Income Levels

Here's how much Colorado income tax changes at four levels of taxable income, comparing the current 4.4% flat rate with the Amendment 87 brackets.

Colorado Taxable Income Tax at 4.4% Flat Tax Under Amendment 87 Difference Effective Rate Under Amendment 87
$500,000 $22,000 $21,675 $325 less 4.34%
$1,000,000 $44,000 $59,925 $15,925 more 5.99%
$2,000,000 $88,000 $143,925 $55,925 more 7.20%
$5,000,000 $220,000 $395,925 $175,925 more 7.92%

I calculated these from the published brackets. They're illustrations, not a prediction of your tax bill, because your actual Colorado taxable income depends on your deductions, adjustments and filing situation.

Marginal rate versus effective rate

The marginal rate is the rate on your last dollar of income. The effective rate is your total tax divided by your total taxable income. Someone with $2 million of taxable income pays 8.4% on the dollars above $1 million, but the overall effective rate works out to about 7.2% because the lower brackets pull the average down.

For timing decisions, the marginal rate is the one that counts. A gain that sits on top of your other income gets taxed at the highest bracket it reaches.

How a Large Capital Gain Gets Taxed in 2027

Colorado starts with your federal taxable income, and a long-term capital gain is taxed at the state's regular income tax rate. The state doesn't have a lower rate for long-term gains the way the federal system does. Colorado has a subtraction for certain qualifying property, but gains from publicly traded stocks, ETFs and mutual funds don't automatically qualify. Ask your CPA whether any of your gains do.

That means a large gain stacks on top of your other income and gets taxed at the bracket it lands in. Here's an example.

An investor has $1 million of other taxable income and a stock position with a $1 million gain.

Colorado Tax on a $1 Million Gain, Sold in 2026 or 2027

The investor has $1 million of other taxable income each year. Bar length shows the relative amount of Colorado tax on the gain.

Sold in 2026 (4.4% flat)
$44,000
Colorado tax on the $1 million gain
Sold in 2027 (8.4% bracket)
$84,000
Colorado tax on the same gain

Illustration based on the Amendment 87 brackets published in the Colorado Legislative Council Blue Book. Federal tax is not included and does not change with this example.

This is a simplified hypothetical, not a projection of any individual's tax bill.

In this example, selling in 2026 cuts the Colorado tax on the gain by $40,000. If the same investor had little other income in 2027, the gain would spread across lower brackets and the difference would be much smaller.

That's why the answer depends on your own numbers. The same gain can cost very different amounts in tax depending on what else is going on in your 2027 return.

When Selling in 2026 Makes Sense, and When It Doesn't

Selling early can save state tax, but it also has costs. These are the questions I work through with clients.

Were you planning to sell anyway?

Accelerating a sale only saves money if the sale was going to happen in 2027 or later. If you planned to hold the shares for decades, give them to charity or leave them to heirs, selling now creates a tax bill you might never have owed. Heirs generally receive a step-up in cost basis, which can erase the built-in gain.

What does selling early do to your federal tax?

The federal capital gains rates aren't changing, so this decision doesn't help or hurt you there. But selling a large position this year can push you into the 20% federal bracket and trigger the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax. Check the federal impact alongside the Colorado savings.

What is the cost of paying the tax sooner?

If you sell in 2026, you pay the tax in April 2027 instead of a year or more later. The money you send to the IRS and Colorado can't keep growing in your portfolio. A state tax savings of a few percentage points can outweigh that cost, but it won't always.

Does a higher 2026 income affect anything else?

A larger gain in 2026 can raise your Medicare premiums two years later through the income-related surcharge, and it can affect eligibility for certain credits and deductions. If you're 63 or older, check this before you sell.

Are you planning to move?

Colorado taxes residents on their income. If you expect to change your state of residence, the comparison between 2026 and 2027 changes, and you should talk to a tax professional about how a move would work for your situation.

How soon do you need to act?

There are about six weeks left in 2026. A sale counts toward the year when the trade executes, so place orders early enough to complete before the last trading day. If you want to give shares to charity or run a multiyear tax projection first, start now rather than in the last week of December.

Why the Investment Risk Matters as Much as the Tax Savings

If most of your gain sits in one stock, the tax question shouldn't crowd out the risk question. Holding a large position just to avoid or delay a tax bill can cost far more than the tax itself if the stock falls.

Hendrik Bessembinder, a finance professor at Arizona State University, studied individual U.S. stock returns going back to 1926 in his paper Do Stocks Outperform Treasury Bills? Most individual stocks had lifetime returns below one-month Treasury bills, and about 4% of listed companies accounted for all of the net wealth the U.S. stock market created. The rest, taken together, only matched Treasury bills.

That doesn't mean stocks are poor investments, because the broad market has created a lot of wealth. It means that a single company is a much less reliable bet than the market as a whole. If you own a stock that has done very well, you hold one of the winners, but nothing guarantees it stays one.

So when a state tax change makes 2026 a cheaper year to sell, it can be a good reason to reduce a position you were already uncomfortable with. I go through the research in more detail in my article on managing a large Nvidia position.

Common Situations: Concentrated Stock, Equity Compensation, Business Sales and Roth Conversions

A large single-stock position

If you hold a big position in a stock like Nvidia, you may already be thinking about whether to sell for diversification reasons. The new Colorado brackets add a timing question to that decision. You can read more about the investment side in my article, Should You Sell Nvidia Stock?

If you want to reduce the position anyway, 2026 may be a good year to sell a larger portion than you'd otherwise choose. If you're comfortable with the position, the state tax change alone usually isn't enough reason to sell.

Employer stock and equity compensation

Executives and long-time employees may have restricted stock units, stock options or shares from an employee stock purchase plan. Income from RSU vesting and option exercises is taxed as wages, so those events add to your Colorado taxable income in the year they happen.

If you control the timing of an option exercise, ask whether exercising in 2026 makes sense. If your RSUs vest on a fixed schedule, you can still plan the sale of the shares, and you can compare how much income lands in each year.

Selling a business

The sale of a business can create one very large year of income. If the closing date is flexible, a deal that closes in December could be taxed at 4.4% instead of 7.4% to 8.4%. A deal date shouldn't change for tax reasons alone, but it's a good question to raise with your attorney, CPA and the buyer early.

If you own a pass-through entity, ask your CPA how Colorado's pass-through entity tax election might interact with the new brackets.

Roth conversions and other large income events

A Roth conversion adds to your taxable income in the year you do it. If you were planning a large conversion in 2027, converting in 2026 at the 4.4% state rate may save tax. If you're thinking about doing several smaller conversions over a few years to stay below $500,000, the new brackets may fit your plan better than a single large one.

Rental and investment property

A sale of a rental property, a second home or a family cabin can produce a gain large enough to reach the higher brackets, especially when depreciation recapture is added in. If you're thinking about selling a property in the next year or two, include it in your projection.

Other Ways to Manage the Tax

Selling in 2026 isn't your only option. Depending on your situation, one of these may work better or in combination.

1. Spread the gain across several years.

Since the first $500,000 of taxable income is taxed at 4.4% or less, you may be able to realize gains over several years and keep each year's income near that line. That works best when you aren't in a hurry to reduce the position.

2. Harvest losses to offset gains.

Selling investments that have lost value can offset realized gains. The wash sale rules apply, so coordinate the trades carefully.

3. Donate appreciated shares.

If you already give to charity, donating appreciated stock directly to a qualified charity or a donor-advised fund can avoid the capital gains tax on those shares. Because Colorado starts from your federal income, a deduction in a high-income year can also be worth more than in a low-income year.

4. Use an installment sale for a business or property.

Spreading payments across several years can keep each year's income lower. The tax rules for installment sales are detailed, so work with your CPA.

5. Time deductions and income together.

Large charitable gifts, retirement plan contributions and business deductions can reduce taxable income in a year when you expect a big gain.

How to Compare 2026 and 2027 With a Multiyear Projection

The right way to decide is to model the full tax picture instead of looking only at the Colorado rate. For a client with a large position, I build a projection that includes:

  • Expected income from all sources in 2026, 2027 and a few years beyond.
  • The cost basis of each tax lot, so we can see which shares to sell first.
  • Federal capital gains rates, the Net Investment Income Tax and any effect on Medicare premiums.
  • The Colorado tax under the current flat rate and under the new brackets.
  • The after-tax outcome of selling in 2026, selling over several years and holding.
  • How each choice fits your retirement income plan, charitable goals and estate plan.

Often the best answer is a partial sale in 2026, some sales in later years and a gift of shares to charity. Sometimes it's to do nothing. The projection shows which one fits your numbers.

A tax deadline is a different kind of reason to act than a political headline. If you're also wondering whether the election results should change your portfolio, I look at that question separately in what the 2026 midterm results mean for investors.

A Colorado tax change also shouldn't override your risk concerns. If you have too much of your wealth in one stock, that's a reason to sell on its own, and a lower state tax rate this year simply makes 2026 a more attractive time to do it.

Planning a Large Stock Sale Before Year End?

If you hold a large gain in stock, options or a business and expect your 2027 income to exceed $500,000, Inclinevest Wealth Management can help you compare your options before the year ends.

Our work combines comprehensive financial planning and investment management, including tax-aware diversification, multiyear tax projections, retirement income planning and coordination with your CPA.

Inclinevest Wealth Management is a Colorado-based, fee-only fiduciary registered investment adviser serving individuals and families nationwide.

Schedule an Introductory Conversation View Services & Fees

Frequently Asked Questions About Amendment 87 and Selling Stock

When does Colorado's graduated income tax start?

Amendment 87 creates the graduated brackets starting in tax year 2027. Income earned in 2026 is still taxed at the current 4.4% flat rate.

What is the top Colorado income tax rate under Amendment 87?

The top rate is 8.4% on taxable income above $1 million. The rate is 7.4% on income from $500,001 to $750,000 and 7.9% on income from $750,001 to $1 million.

Should I sell my appreciated stock in 2026 to avoid the higher Colorado rates?

It can make sense if you expect to sell soon anyway and your 2027 taxable income would exceed $500,000. If you expect to stay under that level, or you planned to keep the shares for a long time, the state tax change usually isn't a strong reason to sell. Compare the Colorado savings with your federal tax, the cost of paying tax earlier and your overall goals.

Does Amendment 87 raise taxes for most Coloradans?

No. The Legislative Council estimated that taxpayers with Colorado taxable income below $510,834 would pay slightly less, by up to $325 a year, and taxpayers above that level would pay more.

How are capital gains taxed in Colorado?

Colorado taxes capital gains as part of your taxable income at the state's regular rate. Starting in 2027, a large gain can be taxed at the higher brackets, depending on how much other income you have that year. Some gains may qualify for a Colorado subtraction, so ask your CPA about your situation.

Does Amendment 87 apply to businesses?

Yes. The graduated rates apply to businesses as well as individuals. If you own a business, talk with your CPA about how the new brackets and any pass-through entity tax election affect you.

Could I donate appreciated stock instead of selling it?

If you already plan to give to charity, donating appreciated shares directly to a qualified charity or donor-advised fund can avoid the capital gains tax on those shares and may provide an income tax deduction, subject to limits.

Should I do a Roth conversion in 2026 instead of 2027?

A Roth conversion adds to your Colorado taxable income in the year you convert. If you expect your 2027 income to exceed $500,000, a conversion in 2026 would be taxed at 4.4% instead of the higher brackets. A projection that includes federal tax and Medicare premiums can show which year works better.

Does Inclinevest Wealth Management work with clients outside Colorado?

Yes. Inclinevest Wealth Management is based in Colorado and works with clients across the country. The firm provides comprehensive financial planning and investment management for individuals and families, including Colorado residents with large appreciated positions.

Research and Additional Resources

This article is for educational purposes and is not individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Tax law changes frequently and Amendment 87 is newly approved, so details may change as the state issues guidance. Examples are hypothetical and exclude federal tax unless noted. Investment decisions should be based on an individual's financial circumstances, objectives, tax situation and risk tolerance. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Consult appropriate tax and legal professionals regarding your specific situation.

Inclinevest Wealth Management is a Colorado-based, fee-only fiduciary registered investment adviser serving clients nationwide. Investments are held at Charles Schwab.

Gabriel Motta CFP Defense financial advisor
About Author

Gabriel Motta, CFP®, MBA is the founder of Inclinevest. He is a Certified Financial Planner™ professional and a member of NAPFA and the XY Planning Network. As a fee-only fiduciary advisor, he is committed to objective, client-first advice. If anything here raised questions about your own situation, feel free to reach out.