Gabe Motta, CFP®, MBA, AWMA™Founder & Wealth Advisor
FEE-ONLY FIDUCIARY | RETIREMENT PLANNING | INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT
Retiring During a Stock Market Decline? What to Do With Your Investments
I'm Gabe Motta, a financial planner based in Colorado. I work with pre-retirees, retirees, and successful professionals across the country, and whenever markets fall, a lot of them ask me the same thing: what happens to my retirement if the market keeps falling?
Stocks don't just go up. They go up, they go down, and sometimes they go nowhere for a very long time. If you're retiring now, or already living off your portfolio, that matters more than almost anything else in your financial life.
Market declines are a normal part of investing, and they have a way of showing up at the worst possible time. A 10% drop isn't the real problem. The real problem is what happens if it turns into something longer and you don't have a plan for it.
Investments at Charles Schwab
Based in Colorado, Serving Clients Nationwide
CFP® Professionals
Fee-Only
Fiduciary
NAPFA
XYPN
What Should You Do If You're Retiring During a Stock Market Decline?
Don't make big moves because of headlines, and don't count on a quick rebound. The retirees who come through downturns well have a written plan. It spells out how much risk they can really afford, where their next few years of spending come from so they're never forced to sell stocks at a loss, how their portfolio is mixed across asset classes, and how they'll adjust their spending and taxes when markets get rough.
If you can't point to those things today, fixing that comes before any investment decision.
The Short Version
- The S&P 500 has gone nowhere for a decade at a time. A plan that depends on a fast recovery is a bet.
- Poor returns early in retirement do far more damage than the same returns later, because you're selling while prices are down.
- The mix of investments you own matters more than which single stock or fund you picked.
- Most people don't know their real risk tolerance until a decline tests it.
- A plan built before the next downturn is worth far more than a reaction after it starts.
Stocks Don't Always Go Up
The most dangerous belief in investing is that the market always bounces back fast. It usually recovers eventually. But eventually can be a very long time when you're withdrawing money to live on.
| Period | What the S&P 500 did | What it meant for retirees |
|---|---|---|
| Late 1960s to early 1980s | Little to no net gain in nominal terms, with high inflation eating away at purchasing power for well over a decade. | Retirees who needed their portfolio to keep up with rising costs fell behind. |
| 2000 to 2009 | A full decade with a slightly negative total return, including two severe bear markets. | Someone who started withdrawing in 2000 spent ten years pulling money out of a portfolio that went nowhere. |
| The 1930s | A collapse followed by a slow, multi-year recovery. | Recovery took far longer than most people assume. |
These periods aren't rare footnotes. They're part of the record that any serious retirement plan has to survive. A plan that only works if the S&P 500 keeps going up isn't a plan.
Most people miss this. During the 2000s, portfolios spread across bonds, international stocks, emerging markets, and small-company value stocks had a very different experience from portfolios that owned only large U.S. stocks. The market didn't go nowhere for everyone. It went nowhere for the people who owned one corner of it.
Why a Decline Hurts More Early in Retirement
While you're working, a market decline is a sale. You buy more shares at lower prices. In retirement the math flips. You're selling, so a decline forces you to sell more shares to raise the same dollars, and those shares aren't there when the recovery comes.
This is called sequence-of-returns risk. The order in which returns show up matters when you're taking money out. Two retirees can earn the same average return over 30 years and end up in very different places, because one got the bad years first and the other got them last.
Say you planned to withdraw $120,000 a year from a $3 million portfolio. That's a 4% withdrawal rate. If the portfolio falls to $2.4 million, the same $120,000 is now 5% of what's left. You haven't spent a dollar more, but the portfolio is working a lot harder just to keep up.
What It Looks Like With Real Numbers
Two retirees, same three years of returns
Both start with $1,000,000 and withdraw $50,000 at the start of each year. Both earn the same three annual returns: -20%, +10%, and +15%. The only difference is the order.
| Year | Retiree A | A's balance | Retiree B | B's balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | -20% | $760,000 | +15% | $1,092,500 |
| 2 | +10% | $781,000 | +10% | $1,146,750 |
| 3 | +15% | $840,650 | -20% | $877,400 |
With no withdrawals, both would finish with exactly $1,012,000. With withdrawals, Retiree A ends up about $36,750 behind after only three years, and the gap keeps growing because A has fewer shares around for every future recovery. This is a hypothetical that leaves out taxes, fees, and inflation.
Where each retiree ended up
Each started with $1,000,000 and withdrew $50,000 per year.
Retiree A didn't do anything wrong. They just had bad timing. That's the risk a real retirement plan is built to manage, and a portfolio on its own can't manage it.
The Mix Matters
When markets fall, most people ask whether they should sell. The better question is what they own in the first place.
How your portfolio is divided among stocks, bonds, and cash, and how those pieces are spread across regions, company sizes, and types of bonds, is the main driver of how it behaves in a downturn. It matters more than which stock you picked or which fund had the best last year.
Plenty of investors think they're diversified and aren't. Owning a dozen funds that all hold the same big U.S. technology companies is one bet wearing several names. When a handful of mega-cap companies make up a large share of an index, a portfolio built on that index can be far more concentrated than it looks. If that corner of the market struggles, so does everything tied to it.
Real diversification means owning assets that behave differently from each other. It can't prevent losses, and in a severe crisis a lot of things fall together. But it's one of the few tools with a long record of improving your odds through the lost decades. The right mix for you depends on your income needs, your taxes, and how much risk you can actually take. That's a planning question, and a fund fact sheet can't answer it.
We're Unapologetically Evidence Based
At Inclinevest, we have one investment philosophy, and we don't apologize for it. We invest according to the known drivers of expected returns, backed by decades of academic research, instead of relying on forecasts, market predictions, or attempts to time the market. We don't speculate.
In practice, that means globally diversified portfolios, low-cost investments, disciplined rebalancing, and careful attention to taxes. We build around what you can control, which is your asset allocation, your costs, your taxes, your risk, and your behavior when markets get ugly.
A falling market is where that approach earns its keep. Nobody knows what the S&P 500 will do next month or over the next ten years. We'd rather build a portfolio and a plan that can handle either answer. You can read more about how we invest on our investment philosophy page.
Do You Really Know Your Risk Tolerance?
Almost everyone thinks they have a high tolerance for risk when markets are rising. It's a different question when your statement shows a six-figure loss and you're about to take a distribution from it.
Risk also isn't one number. Your tolerance is how much ups and downs you can live with without abandoning your plan. Your capacity is how much loss your finances can absorb without changing your lifestyle. And the risk you need to take depends on what return your goals actually require.
Those three often disagree. Someone with a high tolerance but low capacity can get into real trouble. Someone with low tolerance and big goals faces a hard conversation. Measuring all three, and building a portfolio that respects the lowest of them, is one of the most important steps in a retirement plan. Guessing doesn't work.
Asset Allocation and Fixed Income
A market decline doesn't automatically mean you should get more conservative. Selling stocks after a drop can lock in the loss and leave you under-invested for the recovery. But holding too much in stocks can leave you exposed to a decline you can't afford. There's no rule of thumb that gets this right for everyone. The right mix of stocks, bonds, and cash comes out of your plan.
Fixed income has a specific job in a retirement portfolio. It helps fund spending, it softens volatility, and it gives you something to sell when stocks are down. Not every bond does that job well, though. Long-term bonds, lower-quality bonds, and bonds bought only for their yield can behave very differently than people expect. In 2022, stocks and bonds fell together as interest rates climbed. The stable part of a portfolio has to be designed on purpose.
Why Retirees Need a Plan for Cash and Safe Money
One of the best protections against sequence-of-returns risk is making sure you're never forced to sell stocks at a loss to pay your bills. Many retirees do this by sorting their portfolio into time-based buckets.
| Bucket | What it's for |
|---|---|
| Cash reserve | Pays for near-term spending so a market decline doesn't force a sale. |
| Stability bucket | High-quality fixed income that refills the cash reserve and cushions the portfolio while stocks recover. |
| Growth bucket | Long-term investments that keep you ahead of inflation over a retirement that can last 30 years or more. |
The idea sounds simple. The details are where plans succeed or fail. How big should each bucket be for your spending? What goes in each one? What triggers a refill, and what happens if stocks are still down when the cash runs low? How do taxes affect which accounts fund which bucket? The answers are different for every household, and a generic rule can be dangerously wrong.
Want to see how this would work for your portfolio?
We'll map your spending, income sources, and accounts into a plan built for a falling market. Meetings are available in person in the Denver area or by video anywhere in the country.
Schedule an IntroductionHow Much Can You Withdraw?
The 4% rule says you can withdraw 4% of your portfolio in the first year of retirement, then adjust that dollar amount for inflation each year. It was built on historical data and a fixed time frame. It's a starting point and not a promise.
Morningstar's December 2025 retirement income research estimated a 3.9% base-case starting withdrawal rate for a 30-year retirement, assuming inflation-adjusted spending and a 90% probability of having money left at the end. It also found that retirees willing to adjust their spending could potentially support higher starting rates. Those results rest on specific assumptions and aren't guarantees.
Your sustainable rate is personal. It depends on how much of your spending is essential versus flexible, when your income sources start, your allocation, your taxes, and how you'd respond to a bad market. Retirees who decide those responses in advance, with clear spending rules, handle downturns much better than the ones who improvise under stress.
Mistakes That Quietly Damage Retirements
- Selling after the market has already fallen, which locks in the loss and often means missing the recovery.
- Believing the market always bounces back quickly. Sometimes it takes a decade or more.
- Sitting in too much cash for too long and letting inflation eat away at it.
- Owning a "diversified" portfolio that's really one big bet.
- Chasing high dividend yields. An unusually high yield can signal a falling price or a payout that can't last.
- Reaching for yield in bonds, which makes the safe part of the portfolio the risky part.
- Planning around average returns instead of the order of returns.
- Having no written withdrawal plan, so fear ends up making the decisions.
Can You Answer These Questions Today?
A real retirement plan answers every one of these with specifics. If you can't, you're not alone, but you're exposed.
- What are my actual risk tolerance, risk capacity, and the risk I need to take, and does my portfolio match them?
- If stocks stay flat or fall for ten years, does my plan still work?
- How many years of spending are protected from stock market declines?
- Which accounts and investments would I sell first, and why?
- How much could I trim spending in a bad market without changing my life?
- Is my portfolio truly diversified, or does it depend on a few companies?
- How do my taxes, Social Security timing, and withdrawals fit together?
- What would a 30% decline do to my income in the first year of retirement?
These are the questions we answer in every retirement plan, using your actual numbers. We don't use a rule of thumb, and we don't use a calculator that assumes the market goes up every year.
About the author: Gabe Motta, CFP®, MBA, AWMA™
Gabe is the founder of Inclinevest Wealth Management, a fee-only fiduciary firm based in Greenwood Village, Colorado. He helps pre-retirees, retirees, and successful professionals with retirement income planning, tax-efficient withdrawals, and evidence-based portfolios built to hold up in difficult markets. His background includes time at BBVA, U.S. Bank, and UBS.
Retiring in an Uncertain Market? Start With a Real Plan.
Inclinevest Wealth Management is an independent, fee-only fiduciary firm. We're based in Greenwood Village, Colorado, and we serve pre-retirees, retirees, and successful professionals throughout the south Denver area, across Colorado, and nationwide through secure video meetings.
A plan with us goes well beyond picking investments. It typically includes:
- A risk assessment that measures your tolerance, your capacity, and the return you need, so your portfolio matches your reality.
- A retirement income plan that shows where each year of spending comes from, including a cash and safe-money strategy.
- A globally diversified, evidence-based portfolio built around your plan.
- Stress tests that show how your plan holds up through a lost decade and not just an average one.
- Tax-efficient withdrawals, Social Security strategy, and Roth conversion analysis.
- Guidance on equity compensation and inherited accounts, where they apply.
We're affiliated with NAPFA, XY Planning Network, and the Fee-Only Network, and client assets are held at Charles Schwab. We don't earn commissions, so our only job is to do what's best for you.
Schedule an Introduction Explore Our Services & FeesFrequently Asked Questions About Retiring During a Stock Market Decline
Is it a bad time to retire if the stock market is down?
Not automatically. Timing matters less than whether your plan has dependable income, a way to fund spending without selling stocks at a loss, and an allocation that matches your real risk capacity. A prepared retiree can retire into a downturn. An unprepared one can struggle even in a rising market.
What is sequence-of-returns risk?
It's the danger that poor investment returns early in retirement, combined with ongoing withdrawals, can shorten the life of a portfolio. The order of returns matters because selling investments after losses leaves fewer assets to take part in a recovery.
Has the S&P 500 ever gone down over a 10-year period?
Yes. The S&P 500 posted a slightly negative total return over the decade from 2000 through 2009, and it went essentially nowhere in nominal terms for much of the late 1960s through the early 1980s, with inflation eating away at purchasing power. Diversified portfolios fared differently than portfolios concentrated in large U.S. stocks.
Should I move my retirement savings to cash if the market crashes?
Usually not entirely. Moving everything to cash can lock in losses, risk missing a recovery, and leave you exposed to inflation over a long retirement. The right amount of cash depends on your spending, your other income, and your overall plan.
What is the bucket strategy for retirement?
It organizes a portfolio by time horizon, typically with a cash reserve for near-term spending, a stability bucket of high-quality fixed income, and a growth bucket for the long term. It's designed to reduce the chance of selling stocks when prices are depressed. The right structure depends on your individual plan.
What is a reasonable withdrawal rate for a 30-year retirement?
The 4% rule is a starting point and not a guarantee. Morningstar's December 2025 research estimated a 3.9% starting withdrawal rate for a 30-year retirement under its base-case assumptions. Your sustainable rate depends on your allocation, spending flexibility, taxes, and market conditions.
What does evidence-based investing mean?
Evidence-based investing means building portfolios around the known drivers of expected returns, supported by decades of academic research, instead of forecasts or market timing. It focuses on diversification, low costs, tax management, risk control, and disciplined behavior.
Does Inclinevest work with retirees outside of Colorado?
Yes. Inclinevest Wealth Management is based in Greenwood Village, Colorado, and serves clients throughout the south Denver area, across Colorado, and nationwide. Meetings are held in person locally or by secure video for clients in other states.
How does a fee-only fiduciary help someone retiring in a downturn?
A fee-only fiduciary is paid directly by clients and not through product commissions, and is obligated to act in the client's best interest. In a downturn, that means building a withdrawal strategy, measuring risk, designing liquidity, planning taxes, and coordinating Social Security without a conflict over what to recommend.
Plan for the Market You Might Get
Markets rise, fall, and sometimes stall. The retirees who do well usually aren't the ones who guessed the market right. They're the ones who had a plan that worked in every version of it, and who knew their numbers before the next downturn showed up.
If you're getting close to retirement or already living off your portfolio, now is a good time to find out where you really stand. We'd be glad to help.
Schedule an IntroductionSources and Further Reading
This article is for educational purposes and isn't individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Retirement planning decisions should be based on an individual's financial circumstances, objectives, tax situation, risk tolerance, and time horizon. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. Diversification doesn't ensure a profit or protect against loss. Past performance doesn't guarantee future results. Hypothetical examples are for illustration only and don't represent actual client results. Tax laws and individual circumstances vary. Consult appropriate tax and legal professionals about your specific situation.
Inclinevest Wealth Management is a Colorado-based, fee-only fiduciary registered investment adviser serving clients nationwide. Investments are custodied at Charles Schwab.

Social Security and Taxes in a Down Market
Two of the most valuable levers in a retirement plan are also two of the easiest to get wrong in a downturn.
Every dollar of dependable income reduces how much you have to take from a falling portfolio, and when you claim Social Security is one of the biggest decisions you'll make. Delaying isn't automatically the right call if it forces heavy withdrawals from a down portfolio in the meantime.
Taxes work the same way. Down markets can create real opportunities, including tax-loss harvesting, Roth conversions at lower account values, and smarter handling of required minimum distributions. They can also create costly mistakes, like wash-sale violations, higher Medicare IRMAA premiums, and conversions that push you into a higher bracket. The right move depends on your income, your accounts, and the years ahead, and today's account balance alone won't tell you.