Alternative Investment Risks: What Investors Should Know Before Committing Their Money
Private equity, venture capital, exchange funds, and tax-aware strategies can have a place in a portfolio. Getting in is easy. Getting out can be expensive.
- Someone has pitched you a private equity, venture capital, or private credit fund.
- You're considering an exchange fund, an Opportunity Zone fund, or a tax-aware strategy for a large appreciated position.
- You already own alternatives and want to know whether the fees, lockups, and complexity are paying off.
There's always another strategy promising better returns, lower taxes, less volatility, or some mix of all three. The pitch is usually the same: traditional investing isn't enough, and you need something more sophisticated.
I'm skeptical of that pitch. In my experience, investors mix up complexity and sophistication, smooth statements and lower risk, and deferring a tax bill and actually saving taxes. The sales conversation spends most of its time on why you should get in and very little on what happens afterward. I think of some of these strategies as financial versions of the Roach Motel: you can check in, but checking out can get expensive.
Why Alternative Investments Are So Appealing
Part of the draw is that they sound exciting. Private equity, venture capital, and exclusive funds give you the feeling of being on the inside, with access to something most people can't buy. We hear about the early backers of famous companies and rarely about the funds that lost money or stayed locked up for years. Next to a plain index fund, that can make an ordinary portfolio feel boring. The appeal also reaches well beyond the wealthy, as more of these products get marketed to everyday investors.
The appeal makes sense. It also fades fast. When the investment loses money, or you need cash for a tax bill, a medical expense, or a family emergency and can't get it out, the exclusivity doesn't mean much. What matters then is what it cost, how long your money is tied up, and whether you can get it back.
Before you buy something because it sounds sophisticated, picture owning it when it's down and you need the money. Investments you can understand, price every day, and sell when you need to have a lot going for them.
Why Exiting Can Cost More Than Entering
Liquidity is your ability to get at your money when you need it, whether that's to pay a tax bill, help a family member, fund retirement, or change course, without a big penalty. Many alternatives restrict that in three ways:
- Lockups and holding periods. Your capital may be committed for seven to ten years or longer.
- Exit taxes. Tax-deferral strategies often accumulate embedded gains, so leaving can trigger the bill you set out to defer.
- Redemption restrictions. Gates, notice periods, and suspensions tend to appear when many investors want out at the same time.
Say an investor holds $1,000,000 of a single stock with a cost basis of $100,000 and considers contributing it to an exchange fund. Selling outright would realize a $900,000 gain. Many exchange funds have a seven-year contractual holding period, but the redemption terms and tax treatment depend on each fund's structure and documents.
| Item | Getting in | Getting out |
|---|---|---|
| Federal tax at 23.8% on a $900,000 gain | Potentially deferred, versus about $214,200 if sold today | Deferred tax still comes due when the diversified shares are eventually sold |
| Access to the money | Shares committed to the fund | Often around seven years before the intended tax treatment applies |
| Fund fees at an assumed 0.75% per year | $7,500 in year one | About $52,500 over seven years, before growth |
Numbers are simplified and exclude state taxes, growth, and your own tax situation. They show the shape of the trade-off, not a forecast.
Terms can also change after you invest. Fund managers and custodians can adjust fees, borrowing limits, margin rules, or redemption terms, and custodians have tightened the rules on leveraged long-short accounts before. A plan that depends on today's terms lasting for years needs a backup.
Tax Deferral Doesn't Always Mean Tax Savings
A strategy can postpone a tax bill without getting rid of it. Here's what each of these actually does:
- Tax-loss harvesting can offset realized capital gains, subject to the applicable rules.
- Exchange funds can potentially defer recognition of gains when they're structured to qualify for the intended tax treatment.
- Opportunity Zone funds carry specific eligibility, holding-period, and tax requirements.
- Long-short strategies can generate losses, but those losses don't automatically become permanent tax savings. Gains can build up inside the account and come due when you unwind it.
Long-short is also an active strategy, and that's easy to overlook when the tax losses get all the attention. The manager has to choose which stocks to own and which stocks to short, betting that the shorts will lag the market. The portfolio then has to beat the index after paying for leverage, borrowing, and shorting. A manager who picks poorly on either side can leave you with a pile of tax losses and a portfolio that trails what you'd have earned by simply owning the index.
What matters is your after-tax result over the whole holding period, after fees, financing costs, and the tax due when you exit.
Pitched an alternative investment, or already own one?
In a 30-minute conversation, we'll look at how it fits your whole financial plan: costs, exit taxes, liquidity, and what it means for your retirement income.
Schedule a 30-Minute CallCommon Alternatives and Their Trade-Offs
Each of these can fit certain investors, and each comes with trade-offs to understand first.
| Investment | Potential benefit | Important trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Tax-aware long-short | Extra tax-loss harvesting opportunities | The manager has to pick winning longs and shorts, plus leverage, financing and short-selling costs, custodian rules that can change, and exit taxes |
| Exchange funds | Potential tax-deferred diversification of a concentrated position | Long holding periods, limited control, fund-level fees |
| Qualified Opportunity Funds | Potential tax benefits on eligible capital gains | Development and financing risk, long holding periods, limited withdrawals |
| Private equity | Access to privately held companies | Multiple fee layers, valuation uncertainty, illiquidity |
| Hedge funds | Strategies that can profit in different markets | Fees often around 2% plus 20% of profits, so the manager has to beat the market by a wide margin to keep you ahead |
| Venture capital | Exposure to early-stage companies | High failure rates and widely dispersed outcomes |
| Private credit | Potential income from loans to private companies | Redemption limits, valuation uncertainty, and credit risk in a downturn |
| Evergreen private funds | Periodic redemption opportunities | Redemption limits, gates, and suspensions, often when you most want out |
A tax incentive doesn't guarantee a good investment. Evaluate the underlying economics on their own, separate from the tax benefit.
The Total Cost of Complexity
A 1% management fee rarely tells the whole story. Alternative investments can carry several layers of cost:
- Management fees and performance fees or carried interest
- Fund-level operating, legal, and administrative expenses
- Financing, borrowing, and short-selling costs
- Transaction expenses
- Tax preparation and reporting costs
- The opportunity cost of capital you can't access
Hedge funds and many private equity funds have traditionally charged "2 and 20": a 2% management fee on your assets plus 20% of the profits. Some charge less and some charge more, but those headline numbers are common.
Say you invest $1,000,000 in a fund that charges 2 and 20, and the fund earns 10% before fees. The management fee is $20,000. The performance fee is 20% of the remaining $80,000 gain, or $16,000. You keep $64,000, a 6.4% return, so fees took 36% of the profit. If the fund loses 5% before fees instead, you still pay the $20,000 management fee, and your loss grows to about 7%.
The example is simplified and leaves out hurdle rates, high-water marks, and fund expenses, which vary by fund.
So ask this: what extra return can I reasonably expect for these costs, risks, and restrictions? If nobody can give you a clear answer, be careful.
Ask How the Person Recommending It Gets Paid
Alternative investments are often sold, not just recommended. Many come with sales loads, placement fees, commissions, or revenue sharing paid to the firm or advisor who brings the money in, and some advisors earn more for placing these products than for plain index funds. Complex products are also easy to market, because the pitch is exclusive access and sophistication. Not every advisor who recommends one is conflicted, and you should still know the incentives.
Before you invest, ask:
- Are you a fiduciary on this recommendation?
- How are you paid if I invest in this fund?
- Do you or your firm receive any fee, commission, or revenue from the fund company?
- Would you recommend it if you earned the same either way?
Inclinevest Wealth Management is both fee-only and a fiduciary, and the two go together. Only you pay us. We don't take commissions, sales fees, or revenue sharing from any fund company, so nothing in our pay depends on which investment you choose. That makes a fee-only fiduciary the most aligned way to work with an advisor. Read more on why fee-only matters.
Volatility Laundering and Why Private Returns Look Smooth
Public stocks are priced every second of the trading day. Private funds are usually valued quarterly, often using models and manager estimates rather than a market price. That makes private returns look smoother.
Cliff Asness of AQR Capital Management calls this volatility laundering. It helps to keep three things apart:
- Price volatility: how much the reported value moves.
- Economic risk: how much the underlying business or asset can deteriorate.
- Valuation frequency: how often the investment is repriced to reflect changing conditions.
A fund valued quarterly can look steadier than a stock priced every second, even when the risk underneath is about the same. If two similar businesses take the same hit, the one marked quarterly just shows it later, and many investors read that smoother statement as better risk-adjusted performance.
That doesn't mean private investments are bad or that private valuations are wrong. The problem is comparing the two sets of numbers as if they were measured the same way. Read the original: Volatility Laundering, AQR Capital Management.
Public Markets vs. Private Investments
| Consideration | Public markets | Private investments |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Frequent market pricing | Often periodic valuations |
| Liquidity | Generally daily | Often restricted |
| Transparency | Extensive public disclosure | Varies by fund |
| Fees | Often relatively low | Can involve multiple fee layers |
| Diversification | Broad diversification available | Depends on the fund |
| Flexibility | Generally easier to rebalance | Often limited by fund terms |
| Performance evaluation | Observable market returns | Requires added valuation analysis |
This table shows the differences you need to understand before you commit, and public investments aren't always safer or better.
The Case for Evidence-Based Investing
A good strategy should hold up in different economic environments, stay practical to maintain, and leave you room to adjust as your life changes. It shouldn't depend on one manager, one financing arrangement, one tax rule, or one kind of market.
Warren Buffett has long favored businesses with durable competitive advantages, which he calls economic moats. Spotting those companies in advance is hard, and even experienced investors get it wrong. Industries shift, new competitors appear, and technology upends businesses that looked unstoppable.
Evidence-based investing doesn't try to pick them. In a broadly diversified, market-cap-weighted portfolio, companies that grow in value become a bigger part of the portfolio, and companies that fall behind become a smaller part. It adjusts as the market changes, and nobody has to predict which companies will lead the next decade.
A diversified portfolio of low-cost public investments also has practical advantages:
- Broad diversification across thousands of companies, industries, and countries.
- Transparency, with observable prices you can check any day.
- Liquidity, so you can rebalance or raise cash without waiting years for a redemption.
- Lower costs, so more of the return stays with you.
- Flexibility as retirement gets closer or your spending and family needs change.
This approach still has losing years, and stocks can fall sharply. Diversification can't remove market risk, and some alternatives do belong in some portfolios. Judge any strategy on its economics, expected return, risks, and total cost, not on how sophisticated it sounds or how smooth the statements look. Over decades, being able to stick with a strategy, adjust it, and reach your money when you need it counts for a lot. That's the thinking behind our investment philosophy.
10 Questions to Ask Before Putting Money in Any Alternative Investment
- How does it actually make money? Understand the underlying business, securities, or assets.
- What risks am I taking? Consider leverage, concentration, financing, counterparty exposure, and valuation uncertainty.
- What are all the costs? Management fees, performance fees, financing, fund expenses, and transaction costs.
- How do I get my money out? Lockups, gates, notice periods, and exit taxes.
- Can the terms change? Check whether the manager or custodian can change fees, borrowing limits, or redemption terms.
- How are valuations calculated? Realized transactions, estimates, or observable market prices.
- What if it underperforms? Could it create problems elsewhere in your plan?
- Does the tax benefit justify it? Judge the investment on its economics, not just its tax treatment.
- Does it fit my time horizon? A seven- or ten-year hold is a problem if you may need the money sooner.
- Would I make this investment without the tax benefit? If not, be cautious.
Where Alternative Investments Can Fit
A family with a large concentrated stock position may benefit from an exchange fund or a carefully structured diversification plan. An investor with significant excess capital, a long horizon, and real tolerance for illiquidity may be comfortable with a limited private equity allocation. Some investors may find a tax-aware strategy useful despite its added complexity.
Ask whether it solves a specific problem a simpler approach can't solve as well, after fees, taxes, and liquidity. Then ask whether your plan can absorb the extra risk if it doesn't work out. Being exclusive or complicated isn't a reason to own something.
Before Committing to an Investment Strategy, Understand the Trade-Offs
Inclinevest Wealth Management provides comprehensive financial planning and investment management, including concentrated stock positions, existing alternative investments, taxes, and retirement income. If you're weighing a new investment or rethinking one you already own, we'll look at how it fits your whole plan.
We're a Colorado-based, fee-only fiduciary firm serving pre-retirees, retirees, and successful professionals nationwide, with investments custodied at Charles Schwab.
Schedule a 30-Minute Call View Our Services & FeesFrequently Asked Questions About Alternative Investments
Are alternative investments riskier than stocks and bonds?
Not always, but many add risks such as leverage, illiquidity, valuation uncertainty, manager selection, and fees. Judge the risk by the underlying assets and structure, not by the label.
What is volatility laundering?
It's a term popularized by Cliff Asness of AQR Capital Management. It describes how infrequent or smoothed valuations can make private investments look less volatile than their underlying economic risk suggests.
How long do you have to hold an exchange fund?
Many exchange funds have a seven-year contractual holding period, but redemption provisions and tax treatment depend on the fund's structure and documents. Review the fund's terms and talk with a tax professional before contributing shares.
What fees do hedge funds and private equity funds charge?
Hedge funds and private equity funds have traditionally charged a management fee around 2% plus a performance fee around 20% of profits, often called carried interest. Fund expenses, financing costs, and administrative charges can add to the total, so ask for every layer of cost in writing.
Why do some advisors recommend alternative investments?
Some do because the investment fits a specific need. Others may earn sales fees, commissions, or revenue sharing for bringing money into a fund. Ask how your advisor is paid and whether they're a fiduciary on the recommendation.
Why is it hard to get out of tax-aware investment strategies?
Some strategies build up large unrealized gains. Unwinding them can mean selling appreciated positions and triggering the taxes you wanted to defer. Financing terms and margin rules can also affect your ability to stay in or leave.
Do alternative investments belong in retirement portfolios?
Sometimes, in limited amounts. Retirees depend on their portfolios for spending, taxes, and gifts, so liquidity and flexibility matter. Any alternative should add enough expected return, after fees, risks, and restrictions, to justify the added risk.
Should high-net-worth investors use alternative investments?
Some may benefit when an alternative addresses a specific tax, diversification, or investment need. Wealth alone doesn't make someone a good candidate. Weigh the costs, risks, and restrictions against your whole financial plan.
About Inclinevest Wealth Management
Inclinevest Wealth Management provides financial planning and investment management with an emphasis on retirement income, tax-efficient investing, and portfolio construction. Related reading: equity compensation and concentrated stock planning, retirement income planning, planning for high-income professionals, and why fee-only matters. You can also see our services and fees.
- Cliff Asness, AQR Capital Management, "Volatility Laundering," January 6, 2023. Read the article.
This article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It isn't personalized investment, tax, or legal advice, and it shouldn't be relied on as a substitute for guidance specific to your situation. Inclinevest LLC is a registered investment adviser. Registration doesn't imply any level of skill or training. Please consult a qualified professional before making decisions about your own financial circumstances.
